Respuesta :
When angles are restricted to real numbers, Bernhard is correct. The sine function has a range of -1 to 1 (inclusive).
_____
When angles are allowed to be complex numbers, the magnitude of the sine of an angle may exceed 1. In this realm, both Henrik and Bernhard are incorrect.
The sine function, defined for all x, is always between -1 and +1. It begins at (0,0), increases to 1 at x = pi/2, decreases to -1 at x = 3pi/2, and increases to 0 as x reaches pi. Thus, the range is [-1,1], regardless of the value of x. Bernie is correct. Gottfried got fried.